Artificial intelligence (AI) is a powerful technology that can bring many benefits to society, such as improving health, education, security, and productivity. However, AI also poses many challenges and risks, such as ethical dilemmas, social impacts, environmental costs, and governance issues. Therefore, it is important to develop and use AI in a responsible and sustainable way, that respects human values, protects human rights, and promotes social justice.
What is AI ethics?
AI ethics is the study of the moral and societal implications of AI. It aims to ensure that AI is aligned with human values and norms, and that it respects human rights and dignity. AI ethics also addresses the potential risks and harms of AI, such as discrimination, manipulation, deception, exploitation, and violence. AI ethics seeks to promote the positive impacts of AI, such as fairness, inclusion, empowerment, well-being, and social good.
AI ethics is not a fixed or universal set of rules or standards. Rather, it is a dynamic and contextual process of deliberation and dialogue among various stakeholders, such as developers, users, regulators, experts, and affected communities. AI ethics requires constant reflection and evaluation of the goals, methods, outcomes, and impacts of AI systems. It also requires transparency and accountability of the design, development, deployment, and governance of AI systems.
Some of the key ethical principles that are often proposed for AI include:
Beneficence: AI should do good or promote well-being for humans and nonhumans.
Non-maleficence: AI should avoid harm or minimize harm for humans and nonhumans.
Autonomy: AI should respect the freedom and self-determination of humans and nonhumans.
Justice: AI should be fair and equitable for humans and nonhumans.
Explainability: AI should be understandable and interpretable for humans and nonhumans.
Responsibility: AI should be accountable and liable for its actions and consequences for humans and nonhumans.
These principles are not exhaustive or definitive. They may vary or conflict depending on the context, culture, or perspective. They may also need to be balanced or prioritized depending on the situation or trade-off. Therefore, applying these principles to concrete cases requires careful analysis and consultation with relevant stakeholders.
What is AI sustainability?
AI sustainability is the study of the environmental and social impact of AI. It aims to ensure that AI is compatible with the long-term preservation and enhancement of natural resources, ecological systems, human health, social justice, and intergenerational equity. AI sustainability also addresses the potential threats and challenges of AI, such as resource depletion, pollution, climate change, biodiversity loss, social unrest, inequality, and existential risk. AI sustainability seeks to promote the positive contributions of AI, such as efficiency, innovation, conservation, restoration, adaptation, resilience, and global cooperation.
AI sustainability is not a separate or secondary concern from AI ethics. Rather, it is an integral and essential aspect of ethical AI. It recognizes that humans are part of nature, and that our well-being depends on the well-being of other living beings and ecosystems. It also recognizes that our actions have long-term and far-reaching consequences for ourselves and future generations. Therefore, AI sustainability requires a holistic and precautionary approach to the development and use of AI systems.
Some of the key sustainability principles that are often proposed for AI include:
Efficiency: AI should use minimal resources and energy to achieve its goals.
Innovation: AI should foster new solutions and opportunities for environmental and social challenges.
Conservation: AI should protect and preserve natural resources and ecosystems from degradation and depletion.
Restoration: AI should repair and restore damaged or degraded natural resources and ecosystems.
Adaptation: AI should help humans and nonhumans cope with and respond to environmental changes and uncertainties.
Resilience: AI should enhance the ability of humans and nonhumans to recover from or withstand environmental shocks and stresses.
Cooperation: AI should facilitate global collaboration and coordination among humans and nonhumans for environmental and social good.
These principles are not comprehensive or conclusive. They may evolve or differ depending on the context, culture, or perspective. They may also need to be integrated or reconciled depending on the situation or trade-off. Therefore, applying these principles to concrete cases requires careful analysis and consultation with relevant stakeholders.
How does AI Ethics and AI Sustainability overlap?
AI ethics and AI sustainability overlap in many ways, as they both share the common goal of ensuring that AI is beneficial for humanity and the planet. They both require a holistic and interdisciplinary approach that considers the multiple dimensions and stakeholders involved in AI systems. They both emphasize the importance of human-centered design and governance of AI systems that respect human autonomy, agency, and participation. They both call for collaboration and partnership among different actors, such as researchers, developers, users, policy makers, civil society organizations, and international institutions.
However, AI ethics and AI sustainability also have some differences and tensions that need to be addressed. For example:
AI ethics focuses more on the moral values and norms that should guide AI systems, while AI sustainability focuses more on the practical impacts and outcomes of AI systems.
AI ethics tends to adopt a deontological perspective that emphasizes the duties and rights of humans and other moral agents, while AI sustainability tends to adopt a consequentialist perspective that evaluates the costs and benefits of AI systems for humans and the environment.
AI ethics may sometimes conflict with AI sustainability when ethical principles require more resources or energy than sustainable practices. For example, ensuring fairness or explainability of AI systems may increase the complexity or size of AI models or data sets.
AI sustainability may sometimes conflict with AI ethics when sustainable practices compromise ethical values or rights. For example, reducing energy consumption or carbon emissions of AI systems may entail sacrificing privacy or security of data or users.
Therefore, it is essential to find a balance between AI ethics and AI sustainability that can harmonize the moral and practical aspects of AI systems. This requires a dialogue and integration among different disciplines and perspectives that can provide a comprehensive and coherent framework for sustainable AI. Such a framework should include:
A clear definition and vision of what sustainable AI means and what are its goals and indicators.
A set of ethical principles and standards that can guide the design, development, deployment, and governance of sustainable AI systems.
A set of best practices and methods that can help implement sustainable AI systems in various domains and contexts.
A set of tools and metrics that can measure and monitor the performance and impact of sustainable AI systems on humans and the environment.
A set of policies and regulations that can support and incentivize sustainable AI systems at local, national, regional, and global levels.
By developing such a framework for sustainable AI, we can ensure that AI is not only ethical but also environmentally friendly, socially responsible, and economically viable, and that it contributes to the well-being of humans and other living beings in the present and in the future.
How can we foster ethical and sustainable AI?
Ethical and sustainable AI is not a given or a guarantee. It is a goal and a challenge that requires constant effort and vigilance from all actors involved in or affected by AI. It is also a collective and collaborative endeavor that requires the participation and contribution of diverse and inclusive voices and perspectives. Here are some possible steps and recommendations for different stakeholders to foster ethical and sustainable AI:
Developers: Developers should follow ethical and sustainability guidelines and standards for AI design, development, testing, and deployment. They should also adopt ethical and sustainability impact assessments and audits for AI systems. They should also engage with users, experts, and communities to understand their needs, expectations, and feedback for AI systems.
Users: Users should be aware of the ethical and sustainability implications of using AI systems. They should also exercise their rights and responsibilities as AI users, such as informed consent, privacy protection, data ownership, and redress mechanisms. They should also provide their input and evaluation of AI systems to developers, regulators, and civil society.
Policy makers: Policy makers should enact ethical and sustainability laws and regulations for AI governance. They should also establish ethical and sustainability oversight and enforcement bodies for AI compliance. They should also promote ethical and sustainability education and awareness for AI literacy.
Civil society: Civil society should monitor and report on the ethical and sustainability issues and impacts of AI systems. They should also advocate and campaign for ethical and sustainability values and norms for AI culture. They should also mobilize and empower citizens and communities to participate in and benefit from AI development and use.
Conclusion
AI ethics and sustainability are crucial and urgent topics for the present and future of humanity and the planet. They are also complex and dynamic topics that require multidisciplinary and multi-stakeholder dialogue and action. By applying ethical and sustainability principles and practices to AI, we can ensure that AI is not only smart, but also good and green.
Sources for AI ethics and sustainability
The Ethics of Sustainability for Artificial Intelligence: A paper by Seth Baum that argues for a comprehensive and long-term perspective on the ethics of sustainability for AI.
The Ethics of Artificial Intelligence for the Sustainable Development Goals: A book edited by Emanuele Ratti, Francesca Rossi, John P. Sullins, and Mariarosaria Taddeo that explores the ethical and social implications of the use of AI to advance the SDGs.
Understanding artificial intelligence ethics and safety: A guide by the UK Government that provides an overview of the key ethical and safety issues of AI and how to address them.
Sustainable AI: AI for sustainability and the sustainability of AI: A paper by Aimee van Wynsberghe that proposes a definition of sustainable AI as a movement to foster change in the entire lifecycle of AI products towards greater ecological integrity and social justice.
Technological Sustainability and Artificial Intelligence Algor-ethics: A paper by Alessandro Mantini that proposes an ethical framework for the interaction between the human person and technology, with a focus on justice, power of service, freedom-creativity, anthropology, responsibility, eschatology, completion, pacification, meekness/minority, and poor big data.
Comments